Maybe I Do (2023)

Maybe I Do is a romantic comedy that dives into the complexities of marriage and infidelity from the perspectives of two different generations. The story revolves around Michelle and Allen, played by Emma Roberts and Luke Bracey, a young couple eagerly preparing for their wedding. However, their plans take an unexpected turn when they introduce their parents for the first time. Diane Keaton, Richard Gere, Susan Sarandon, and William H. Macy portray their respective parents, each harbouring secrets that could jeopardise the young couple’s plans.

The film, written and directed by Michael Jacobs based on his play, Cheaters, marks his debut as a feature director. Unfortunately, his lack of experience is evident. Maybe I Do struggles with originality, humour, and depth. The plot feels predictable and contrived, relying heavily on clichés and coincidences to create conflict and resolve it. The characters come across as shallow and unlikeable, making it difficult to empathise with their struggles or invest in their search for happiness. The dialogue lacks depth and realism, failing to capture the intricacies of human relationships or the wit necessary for a successful comedy.

The film also fails to fully utilise the talents of its seasoned cast members, who seem to lack chemistry and charisma on screen. Keaton and Gere play Grace and Howard, a married couple engaged in extramarital affairs with Sam (Macy) and Monica (Sarandon), respectively. However, their interactions feel awkward and forced, devoid of genuine spark or emotional depth. Similarly, Roberts and Bracey’s portrayal of Michelle and Allen lacks conviction, as their characters lack personality and chemistry as a couple. Their romance comes across as dull and unremarkable, making it challenging to believe in their love or desire to marry.

Maybe I Do is a disappointing and forgettable film that fails to live up to its promising premise. It falls short in delivering both laughs and romance and lacks the insight and entertainment value one would hope for. In a genre that has seen much better execution by others, it is a movie that makes you wonder: maybe I don’t.

(In cinemas in Australia – check your local movie guide for show times.)