Ebenezer (2026)

Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge tips the brim of his black top hat with a gloved hand in a close-up, his long grey hair and grizzled beard framing a weathered face as he glances sideways, in Ebenezer (2026).

A man stands at the grave of his only friend and finds he has nothing to say. Ti West’s Ebenezer introduces its Scrooge that way, and the choice is sharper than most versions of A Christmas Carol allow themselves. Before the Dickens we know begins, a prologue on a Christmas Eve shows Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen) still alive, sneering at his partner that work is the highest good a man can have. Marley dies. Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp) is the only mourner, and he has no word for a partner of decades.

Seven years on, Marley’s chained ghost arrives with a warning, and three spirits follow, as they must. Nobody comes here for the plot. The question is what a new Scrooge can do inside a shape already filmed with Alastair Sim, with Michael Caine among the Muppets, and with Albert Finney in a musical, and Depp’s answer is attitude.

He plays Scrooge broad and theatrical, a snarling, gnarled figure rather than a sweet old man waiting to emerge. Sometimes he tips over into caricature. Yet when the spirits start showing him things, his reactions (dismay, wonder, a slow grief) give the character a pulse that the bellowing alone would never supply. This is a man with something rotten and something wounded in him at the same time, and the combination feels fresh even though every turn of his arc is familiar.

The darkness is the larger surprise. West treats the ghost story inside Dickens as a ghost story, and for most of its 115 minutes the film plays as horror dressed for Christmas. Checco Varese’s photography is darkly lit, while Eve Stewart’s period design makes Scrooge and Marley’s office one of the film’s best-realised spaces. Andrea Riseborough’s Ghost of Christmas Past is white, gaunt, and whispering, and the visit to a bullied boy lands as hard as any jump scare. Tramell Tillman plays the Ghost of Christmas Present, and Rupert Grint makes a sympathetic Bob Cratchit.

What the darkness buys is stakes. A Scrooge nudged along by gentler ghosts changes cheaply; a Scrooge who has been properly frightened has paid for it. Marley’s own fate, tormented for time squandered, argues that a life measured by work leaves a debt behind, and the horror gives that debt weight. The bullied boy gives me pause. Handing Scrooge a wound turns his hardness into something we can explain, and I couldn’t tell whether the film wants that explanation to soften our judgement of him.

The weaker side is its loyalty. The tagline promises a story we don’t know, and the plot delivers the one we do, so the novelty lives in tone alone. McKellen’s Marley is so good, and so brief, that I missed him once he went; the ghosts and grotesque imagery also make the film a poor fit for small children.

Even so, I came away well disposed. This is Dickens for people who like a chill with their Christmas, anchored by a Depp performance that finds the sorrow under the snarl. It’s a good film with real reservations, and worth seeing for anyone who still has patience for one more Scrooge.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

Share your opinion!

Post comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.